Some User Questions
By MB on Tuesday 21 April 2009, 01:14 - Permalink
Here are some questions I received from user and my answers to them.
- No Chelsea? I poked around trying to build an every-minute-on-the-minute thing, but didn't really find one.
Chelsea is tricky to do. It didn't seem to fit into any of the templates that I have so far. I don't think I've ever seen that workout come up since I've been doing CrossFit. To some extent this is a balancing act. There are so many possible ways to structure workouts. If you try to support absolutely every possibility you end up with something very complicated and hard to use. That's why I axed Chelsea. I'll have to take a look at it again and see if I can come up with something.
- I recommend adding abmat sit-ups to the exercise lists
On the abmat situps, I took the attitude that all non-ghd sit-ups are created equal. I haven't actually used an abmat, but I have used a towel and I can't tell that much difference with or without. Again the simplicity-vs-complexity tradeoff comes up. I've tried to strike a balance with the exercises I have. You haven't convinced me on this one yet. Are abmat situps significantly different from floor or towel situps? I'm going to tend to push back on user requests in this area. But if you make a good case, I'll certainly be willing to add exercises (sandbag exercises, farmer-s carry, and waiter's walk for instance are probably ones I would consider adding right now).
- I got an error message about something not being a valid integer... I think it was fixed when I added a 0 to the "seconds" field on the AMRAP workout total time field.
I'm aware that the error messages aren't very informative. That's at the top of our list of things to do after we get a few more important features done.
- It might be worth making a special FGB inputter, with the option of entering individual rounds' and events' scores.
There are two ways to add individual rep counts to FGB. If you don't check "Rxd", it will give you an expanded view and you can customize the details of the workout (including adding reps). Instead of leaving "Rxd" unchecked, you can also submit the workout, then go back and edit it to add individual rep counts. You can't add round totals though. That gets difficult to manage. This is one place where I made a compromise for simplicity. The "Reps Score" template was specifically designed for FGB. You just have to add individual rep counts later.
- I don't see an immediately obvious way to input the 4x800 run, resting as needed.
There are two ways you could do a 4 x 800m run with variable rest. First, you could do it as a time score workout where you put 4 rounds of two exercises, run and rest. Then just add up your times for the each run and put the total in the total time. If you do this, you might want to make some notes about it in the comments section. The other possibility would be to use a custom workout. Put 4 separate 800m run items and the time for each one. The Custom Workout form is designed to be the place you go when none of the other templates work. It's the ultimate in flexibility, but since it has no round structure it takes longer to enter repetitive information.
Comments
New suggestions/comments!
Three WODs per page is a little sparse... could we have 5 to 7, or maybe make it user-controlled?
A condensed view that just lists the date, the WOD name and the time would be pretty cool for personal history.
Making the above possible, it might be nice to optionally enter a name for a custom workout. There are a handful out there that are informally named or aren't HQ-invented (filthy 50, jack bauer, the chief)
I increased it to 10 workouts per page. I might make it user-controlled later.
The "Followed User Activity" page now has a condensed view. Adding that feature for your own workouts is on my todo list.
I've been debating with the issue of allowing people to create their own custom names. I think the existing methods of duplicating previous workouts reduce the need for this feature. I might do it if I can come up with a good way to design it. I think this is a good candidate for a premium feature.
I agree that duplicating previous workouts will mitigate the need to have a name, but it might be tough to FIND those old workouts without having that name. Maybe a search feature that would look in the comments would cover it -- I could just put the custom name in there and then search for it.
I noticed that it jumps to tomorrow's date when you enter a new workout after about 9pm.
Suggestion for premium features:
Community-submitted WODs with a ranking system. So I could make up a WOD, input it, give it a name, and put it in some kind of public directory for the community to see and try out. They could also vote on it (perhaps only after having logged a time for it!) so that the best ones would bubble to the top.
Community-submitted WODs are an interesting idea. Most of that will happen automatically when more users use the site. Instead of requiring users to submit WODs, the site can just take the ones that users log. You implicitly vote for a workout whenever you log it.
Oooh, you could have a "hopper" feature to pick a random WOD out of what people have entered. Then they could rate it after performing it, assuming the site remembered what it had chosen for them so they could find it again after executing.
I entered CFT manually because I didn't see a preset... but that would probably be a candidate for a preset because there's nothing else that totals up your weights like that so it doesn't really fit the mold.
A random workout generator is already on the todo list. That idea alone has a ton of possibilities. I added the CFT. It fits the pattern of a Max Weight workout. The only thing is that it doesn't know to add up the best scores for each lift. I'll work on that. It is ok to use it now because you're storing all the necessary data in the right places.
I would certainly advocate a selector vs. a generator... the common sense element is too valuable to neglect. Not sure which one you had in mind though.
If its not too invasive, could there be a search in the user list for users names instead of just seeing their alias?
Or, a search for certain stats would be another option. Finding users that have similar stats would be an easy way to compare your results against similar bodied people...
Also, adding a country of origin option would be cool to help find people from your country/state/region etc.
Cheers
We don't store users' real names or location information, so that's not available to search. We do have plans to allow some kind of search for users with similar height, weight, performance, etc.
But I was quite right, Joseph Buquet had no business to talk
of things that don't concern him--it will bring him bad luck-mother
was saying so last night----"
There was a sound of hurried and heavy footsteps in the passage
and a breathless voice cried:
"Cecile! Cecile! Are you there?"
"It's mother's voice," said Jammes. "What's the matter?"
She opened the door. A respectable lady, built on the lines of a
Pomeranian grenadier, burst into the dressing-room and dropped groaning
into a vacant arm-chair. Her eyes rolled madly in her brick-dust colored face.
"How awful!" she said. "How awful!"
"What? What?"
"Joseph Buquet
"What about him?"
"Joseph Buquet is dead!"
----------------------------------------------
http://www.nike-star-shoes.net/Nike... Nike Zoom LeBron Playoff
http://www.nike-star-shoes.net/Vinc... Vince Carter Shoes
http://www.nike-star-shoes.net/Nike... Nike Zoom Kobe IV
http://www.nike-star-shoes.net/Nike... Nike Zoom LeBron V
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-M....).html mbt m.walk(black)
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-Sp...).html mbt sport(black)
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-Ch... MBT Chapa
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-M.... MBT M.Walk
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-Sp... MBT Sport
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-La...).html mbt lami women(black)
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-Wi...).html mbt wingu(black)
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-Ch...).html mbt changa women(black)
http://www.mbtshoesstore.net/MBT-Ch...).html mbt chapa (beige)
http://www.airmax-online.net/ nike air max
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 180
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 2009 I
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 360 I
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 87
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 90
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 93
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 95
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max 97
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max Classic BW
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max LTD
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max One Premium
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max Stab
http://www.airmax-online.net/Nike-A... Nike Air Max TN 10
Your views are very good!I very much agree with you, thank you for sharing!
the best jewelry manufacturers in china http://www.chinajewelrysupplier.com
<strong><a href="http://www.chinajewelrysupplier.com" title="jewelry supplier">jewelry supplier</a></strong>
<strong><a href="http://www.chinajewelrysupplier.com" title="jewelry manufacturers">jewelry manufacturers</a></strong> jewelry manufacturers in china
Your views are very good!I very much agree with you, thank you for sharing!
gemstone supplier and gemstone wholesaler:http://www.winbowgems.com
<strong><a href=" http://www.winbowgems.com" title="gemstone supplier">gemstone supplier</a></strong>
gemstone wholesaler in china http://www.winbowgems.com
<strong><a href=" http://www.winbowgems.com" title="gemstone wholesale">gemstone wholesale</a></strong>
Thanks for sharing your article.
As a sports fan I adore all kinds of sports equipments.
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com Coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com coach bags outlet
http://www.guccihandbagsoutlet.com gucci handbags outlet
http://www.guccihandbagsoutlet.com gucci outlet
This article is written by zocy004 on 2010-6-24
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com Coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com coach bags outlet
http://www.guccihandbagsoutlet.com gucci handbags outlet
http://www.guccihandbagsoutlet.com gucci outlet
This article is written by zocy004 on 2010-6-24
http://www.coachoutletmalls.com
This kind of shoes are very especial and beautiful. I recommend it to you. Hope you like it!